Independent data desk. Weather from NOAA, storage from the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA). Information only — not investment advice.
Home › Heating cost

Heating cost · 48 states · EIA prices week of Nov 16

Heating cost by state: gas vs heat pump vs oil vs propane

What a typical 2,000 sq ft home spends on heat in a normal winter, by fuel, at this week's prices. A heat pump is cheapest in 12 states, natural gas in 36; heat pumps beat gas in 12 of 48.

Heating cost calculator

Heating systemFuel per yearCost per yearPer winter month

Model: heat need = annual heating degree days × home heat-loss rate (≈0.25 Btu/h·°F per sq ft, average insulation) × 24 h. Efficiencies: gas and propane 92%, oil 85%, heat pump seasonal COP 2.1–2.4–2.8–3.2 by climate, baseboard 100%. Prices: this week's EIA heating oil and propane, EIA residential gas (winter average) and electricity (12-month average) — U.S. averages where a state isn't surveyed. "Per winter month" ≈ 20% of the year's heating. Estimates, not quotes.

Alabama: cheapest Heat pump $455/yrArizona: cheapest Heat pump $333/yrArkansas: cheapest Heat pump $554/yrCalifornia: cheapest Natural gas furnace $722/yrColorado: cheapest Natural gas furnace $895/yrConnecticut: cheapest Natural gas furnace $1,252/yrDelaware: cheapest Natural gas furnace $912/yrFlorida: cheapest Heat pump $94/yrGeorgia: cheapest Heat pump $444/yrIdaho: cheapest Natural gas furnace $580/yrIllinois: cheapest Natural gas furnace $753/yrIndiana: cheapest Natural gas furnace $718/yrIowa: cheapest Natural gas furnace $861/yrKansas: cheapest Natural gas furnace $788/yrKentucky: cheapest Natural gas furnace $703/yrLouisiana: cheapest Heat pump $236/yrMaine: cheapest Natural gas furnace $1,759/yrMaryland: cheapest Natural gas furnace $881/yrMassachusetts: cheapest Natural gas furnace $1,973/yrMichigan: cheapest Natural gas furnace $862/yrMinnesota: cheapest Natural gas furnace $1,159/yrMississippi: cheapest Heat pump $376/yrMissouri: cheapest Heat pump $859/yrMontana: cheapest Natural gas furnace $855/yrNebraska: cheapest Natural gas furnace $807/yrNevada: cheapest Natural gas furnace $418/yrNew Hampshire: cheapest Natural gas furnace $1,723/yrNew Jersey: cheapest Natural gas furnace $910/yrNew Mexico: cheapest Natural gas furnace $510/yrNew York: cheapest Natural gas furnace $1,212/yrNorth Carolina: cheapest Heat pump $604/yrNorth Dakota: cheapest Natural gas furnace $978/yrOhio: cheapest Natural gas furnace $813/yrOklahoma: cheapest Natural gas furnace $482/yrOregon: cheapest Natural gas furnace $1,044/yrPennsylvania: cheapest Natural gas furnace $991/yrRhode Island: cheapest Natural gas furnace $1,479/yrSouth Carolina: cheapest Heat pump $447/yrSouth Dakota: cheapest Natural gas furnace $908/yrTennessee: cheapest Natural gas furnace $549/yrTexas: cheapest Heat pump $313/yrUtah: cheapest Natural gas furnace $866/yrVermont: cheapest Natural gas furnace $1,526/yrVirginia: cheapest Natural gas furnace $851/yrWashington: cheapest Heat pump $1,161/yrWest Virginia: cheapest Natural gas furnace $781/yrWisconsin: cheapest Natural gas furnace $1,108/yrWyoming: cheapest Natural gas furnace $1,013/yr

Cheapest heating system per state · 2,000 sq ft, average insulation

Natural gas furnace (36)Heat pump (12)

Annual heating cost by state

2,000 sq ft, average insulation, normal winter · click a column to sort

StateHDDNatural gasHeating oilPropaneHeat pumpElectric baseboardCheapest
Alabama2,518$523$1,467$1,331$455$1,456Heat pump
Arizona1,972$436$1,149$792$333$1,067Heat pump
Arkansas3,252$798$1,895$1,207$554$1,552Heat pump
California2,485$722$1,448$998$883$2,826Natural gas
Colorado6,689$895$3,898$2,395$1,757$4,216Natural gas
Connecticut5,778$1,252$3,208$3,634$2,321$5,571Natural gas
Delaware4,407$912$2,644$2,495$995$2,787Natural gas
Florida554$155$323$408$94$300Heat pump
Georgia2,663$525$1,552$1,277$444$1,421Heat pump
Idaho6,714$580$3,913$2,654$1,257$3,016Natural gas
Illinois5,957$753$3,471$1,712$1,651$3,962Natural gas
Indiana5,478$718$3,128$2,133$1,357$3,257Natural gas
Iowa6,706$861$3,550$1,711$1,396$3,350Natural gas
Kansas4,804$788$2,800$1,570$913$2,557Natural gas
Kentucky4,267$703$2,452$1,783$747$2,092Natural gas
Louisiana1,650$358$962$663$236$755Heat pump
Maine7,727$1,759$4,478$4,058$3,830$8,044Natural gas
Maryland4,402$881$2,722$2,482$1,171$3,279Natural gas
Massachusetts6,070$1,973$3,511$3,305$2,703$6,487Natural gas
Michigan6,584$862$3,707$2,388$2,053$4,927Natural gas
Minnesota8,313$1,159$4,490$2,579$2,267$4,761Natural gas
Mississippi2,301$396$1,341$1,048$376$1,202Heat pump
Missouri4,899$892$2,855$1,613$859$2,406Heat pump
Montana7,810$855$4,551$2,534$1,824$3,829Natural gas
Nebraska6,147$807$3,202$1,614$1,148$2,754Natural gas
Nevada3,494$418$2,036$1,403$590$1,653Natural gas
New Hampshire7,199$1,723$4,211$3,998$3,249$6,824Natural gas
New Jersey5,104$910$3,046$2,995$1,776$4,262Natural gas
New Mexico4,307$510$2,510$1,730$1,186$3,320Natural gas
New York5,965$1,212$3,631$3,251$2,500$6,000Natural gas
North Carolina3,250$727$1,861$1,743$604$1,691Heat pump
North Dakota8,951$978$5,216$2,367$1,851$3,887Natural gas
Ohio5,566$813$3,234$2,234$1,502$3,605Natural gas
Oklahoma3,511$482$2,046$1,240$609$1,705Natural gas
Oregon5,251$1,044$3,060$2,109$1,195$2,868Natural gas
Pennsylvania5,550$991$3,141$2,587$1,697$4,072Natural gas
Rhode Island5,649$1,479$3,268$3,320$2,437$5,850Natural gas
South Carolina2,582$544$1,505$1,037$447$1,432Heat pump
South Dakota7,397$908$4,311$2,114$1,769$3,714Natural gas
Tennessee3,712$549$2,163$1,797$634$1,777Natural gas
Texas1,784$402$1,040$816$313$1,003Heat pump
Utah6,296$866$3,669$2,297$1,223$2,936Natural gas
Vermont7,484$1,526$4,290$4,257$2,995$6,290Natural gas
Virginia4,190$851$2,456$2,266$876$2,452Natural gas
Washington5,582$1,173$3,253$2,242$1,161$2,787Heat pump
West Virginia5,027$781$2,929$2,019$1,144$2,746Natural gas
Wisconsin7,297$1,108$3,904$2,217$2,296$4,822Natural gas
Wyoming7,754$1,013$4,519$3,114$1,820$3,821Natural gas

Questions

What is the cheapest way to heat a house?

In our model for an average 2,000 sq ft home, a heat pump is cheapest in 12 states and a natural gas furnace in 36. Heating oil and propane are rarely the cheapest at this week's prices.

Is a heat pump cheaper than gas?

At current EIA prices a heat pump beats a gas furnace on running cost in 12 of 48 states. It loses where electricity is expensive relative to gas, or winters are very cold.

How much does it cost to heat a home with propane?

For a 2,000 sq ft home, from $408 a year in the mildest states to $4,257 in the coldest, at this week's propane prices.

How accurate is this?

It is a model: real bills depend on insulation, thermostat settings, equipment age and your utility's rate. Use it to compare fuels within a state, not as a quote.

Inputs: degree days · natural gas prices · heating oil · propane · electricity · winter outlook · Data: JSON · Markdown