Independent data desk. Weather from NOAA, storage from the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA). Information only — not investment advice.
Home › Guides › Heat Pump vs Propane: Which Is Cheaper to Heat With?

Guide · Heating costs · updated Nov 18, 2026

Heat Pump vs Propane: Which Is Cheaper to Heat With?

At this week's prices a heat pump costs less to run than a propane furnace in 47 of 48 states. State-by-state annual costs and when propane still wins.

Propane averages $2.817 a gallon this week (EIA) and residential electricity 18.0¢/kWh over the last 12 months. Put those through a standard heating model and a heat pump is cheaper to run than propane in 47 of 48 states for a 2,000 sq ft home in a normal winter.

Cost per million Btu of heat

A gallon of propane holds about 91,500 Btu; a 92% furnace delivers ~84,000 of it, so heat from propane costs about $33.46 per million Btu at the U.S. average. A kWh holds 3,412 Btu; a heat pump with a seasonal COP of 2.8 delivers ~9,550 Btu per kWh, so heat costs about $18.88 per million Btu.

State by state

StatePropane / yrHeat pump / yrDifference
Delaware$2,495$995−$1,500
Idaho$2,654$1,257−$1,397
Virginia$2,266$876−$1,390
Connecticut$3,634$2,321−$1,313
Maryland$2,482$1,171−$1,311
Wyoming$3,114$1,820−$1,294
Vermont$4,257$2,995−$1,262
New Jersey$2,995$1,776−$1,220
Tennessee$1,797$634−$1,163
North Carolina$1,743$604−$1,139
Washington$2,242$1,161−$1,080
Utah$2,297$1,223−$1,073

Top 12 states by heat-pump savings; every state is in the heating cost table.

What the running cost leaves out

  • Installation: switching to a heat pump costs thousands; federal and state incentives can cut that.
  • Your actual electricity rate and propane contract — check propane by state and electricity by state.
  • Backup heat: many cold-climate homes keep propane for the coldest days (a dual-fuel setup).

Questions

Is a heat pump cheaper to run than propane?

In most states, yes: at current EIA prices a heat pump is cheaper to run than a 92%-efficient propane furnace in 47 of 48 states for a typical 2,000 sq ft home.

Do heat pumps work in cold climates?

Modern cold-climate heat pumps keep heating below 0°F, but efficiency falls as it gets colder; we use a lower seasonal efficiency (COP 2.1–2.4) for the coldest states.

When does propane beat a heat pump?

Where electricity is expensive and winters are long, or with an older, inefficient heat pump. Propane prices also vary a lot by dealer and contract.

Numbers on this page update automatically from NOAA and EIA data. Not financial or investment advice.